Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Where I stand on...

The System: I was really excited about becoming a math teacher. The idea of joining the ranks of math-lovers and passing on that passion onto students really thrilled me. I knew, of course, there would be many obstacles and challenges along the way, but I was ready to face and master them. Now, I still feel excitement, but trepidation as well. I can’t help but feel as though I am entering a broken system: a system in which the United States is failing international standards, students are not mastering mathematical concepts, teachers teach way too much and yet too little at the same time, our teachers cram to prepare students for high-stakes testing, where the disconnect between elementary math skills and secondary math skills is significant, and a deeper understanding of the concepts and applications of math are losing the battle against drilling formulas and shortcuts, with not just one child, but several children left behind. What do we do? What are new teachers to do? How do we find schools to fit our vision of how to fix the math system? I can go to an interview, armed with my research, my teaching philosophies, my convictions and solutions… but how much freedom does a new, untenured teacher have to make changes? Can we fix things? We can see what’s wrong… but what can we do to make things better? I can teach MY classrooms the way I think is best, but I imagine I’ll need to stay relatively parallel to the other sections of that class. I don’t know what kind of resistance (or applause) to expect by deviating from the way things have been done. I’m sure there are teachers our there who are on a similar mission. I think the smart thing to do is go teach, settle in, get used to it, and then start making changes.

Calculators: I can really identify with what George said in his blog. I noticed the same thing. I’m an aide in several math classes, and teachers encourage students to do the simplest calculations in their calculators. It gets me frustrated enough to see calculators used to add and multiply fractions and negative numbers, let alone adding and multiplying integers!! Just today I had a student who was struggling with 19 x 3. He sat there staring at it for what must have been 5 minutes. The teacher said, “What are you doing? Just do it on the calculator.” When she walked away, I said, “Stop. Think. What do you wish that 19 was?” He said a 20. I said, “So if you multiplied 20 by 3, how much would you be off from the real answer?” He said 1. I said, “Well, yes! But 1, 3 times.” He thought about it and said, “57?” I then showed him that what he just did, in his head, was the distributive property 3 (20 – 1). He seemed proud of himself. Similarly, I had a student take out a calculator to do 1.5 x 3. Or 4-6. Or -1 –(-2). Of course, teachers want their students to be mathematical thinkers, but maybe, in the haste of cramming every lesson in, and preparing students for their standardized tests, they don’t have time to reteach how to do mental math, and maybe they don’t even have the time to wait for them to figure it out for themselves. I asked my teacher about this issue and she said, “You know what? It’s so much easier just to get them to use a calculator. They’re so freaked out they’re going to make a silly mistake anyway, this puts their mind at ease, and I don’t have to take off more points for mental math errors.” While this seems very logical, it makes me sad. I don’t think I’m super fabulous at math – I certainly struggle from time to time… but I know I only struggle when something doesn’t “click” for me. Even if I’m lucky enough to memorize the formulas and know what to plug in where, if I don’t understand it, I won’t do as well. I wish my students WANTED to understand what we’re doing, instead of just wanting to know how to get the answer. Calculators are a fantastic tool to assist in the learning of math, but when high school students are dependent on them for elementary and middle-school calculations, it becomes a problem.

Conceptual Understanding: I mentioned this in class, but the example with the fractions really stuck with me. Even in my basic algebra class, we're solving systems of equations. After three weeks of solving equations, it was time for a test. I asked the teacher if we could put the question, "What does the solution to a system of equations represent?". One student got it right. I think it's so important to get students TALKING and THINKING about mathematical concepts, and to make those processes part of assessment.

The Attitude: I face many of the same struggles as other classmates in student attitude. Loraine's blog really resonated with me. I’m having particular trouble dealing with students’ apathy. I have students who don’t like math, but dutifully plug away at the work. Then I have students who don’t like math, and need a lot of one-on-one attention to get them to participate, and do so reluctantly. Then I have students who don’t bring pencils, put their heads down, and refuse to do any work. They yell, “This is so stupid! When am I ever going to use this?! What’s the point?” It breaks my heart. Partly because they’re so disengaged and angry, and partly because I don’t always have a good answer for them. Due to the nature of the way classes are taught, they don’t see any practical reason to learn math (When will they ever need to calculate the slope of a line?) I feel like it may be valuable, in the beginning of the year, to address the fact that not everything we do will be directly used by them in life, but it will make them sharper, more organized, more logical thinkers. Then, to include as many hands-on activities, games, projects as I can. It's also important to foster a positie attitude about learning math, in general. I'd love to see this done well.

Applications: I think I’ve already blogged this topic to death, but it’s certainly worth mentioning again. I’ve been thinking. I feel the applications of math are paramount in the teaching of math concepts. Even if students never going to see the inside of an engineering room, we can mention that “this kind of math is what has engineers build skyscrapers and bridges” or “this kind of math is what NASA uses to make their astronauts leave the atmosphere” or “this is the kind of math that makes a company decide how much money to invest in commercials.” If students are engaged, they’ll probably learn more efficiently. The key is not only to make your math applications lessons informative, but engaging. I know, sometimes, it’s difficult to make some topics interesting, but I’ve found that if you capture the attention of students early on, they’re more likely to stay with you. There were some teachers whose classes I remember hating because they were so painfully boring, it felt like they were teaching AT us. But the teachers that got excited about math were able to get me excited about it, and I ended up doing very well on standardized tests because I remembered the lessons on that subject.

Monday, March 30, 2009

What I took away from the NSF Projects...

The presentations were really informative. It was great to put myself in the position of a student, observing the lessons. I found a few aspects of them particularly useful. In particular, I definitely want to integrate other disciplines into my curriculum. After watching the CorePlus activity with the Oil Spill of 1989, I found myself really engaged in the math behind the pollution. I like the idea of using mathematics as a vehicle to learn about real-world problems. Students in my classes seem to view math as disconnected form the “real world”. Even my special education freshman, who are learning linear equations, keep demanding, “What is this stuff?? When will I EVER need to know how to graph a line and put the points in a mapping?” Who can blame them? When I’m teaching, I will aim to constantly give real-world applications and anecdotes of the topic at hand, whenever possible. I’d like to incorporate ideas of real-world events, modern-day problems, history, literature, and stories. I believe math should be taught in a way that is meaningful to student, relevant to their lives and interests.

I’d like to have seen more of two things from the presentations. I would have liked to see the hands-on activities and projects assigned in each curriculum. The teachers in my school are always struggling to find projects and activities (with hands-on materials and manipulatives), and often deviate from the text book. I’d have liked to have gotten a flavor of the kinds of long-term, group, and individual projects and activities each of the curricula advises. Another thing I would have liked to see more of was the issue of group work. I find that I can’t really assign my students group work because they seem to have never have learned HOW to work in groups. Either they all get off task, or one person does all the works, or one person does nothing and gets the grade anyway. I don’t know how group work is assessed in the curricula, and how absences are dealt with. I understand this is more of a teacher or school-based decision, but it is worth discussing, I feel.

Thursday, February 26, 2009

Math Applications

As much as I like to think of myself as one, I'm not a teacher yet. I'm what my school calls "instructional support" in special education classrooms in English and Math. Because of my strong academic background, many of my teachers use me as a collaborating teacher (preparing lesson plans, modifying assessments, grading tests, and out-of-class tutoring), but my paycheck says "aide". Whatever. The point is, I'm in the classrooms that have the most basic of math pedagogy. And I feel like I'm witnessing a vicious cycle. I'll be as candid as I ever will, because I didn't give anyone at my school a link to this blog:

The students are viewed as lower-functioning --> The lesson plans are "dumbed down" --> More time is spend on lecturing and drilling --> The students are bored, confused, and frustrated --> They do poorly on tests --> The teachers are bored, confused, and frustrated --> The teacher tries more securing and drilling, which doesn't work --> The students are viewed as lower-functioning. Lather. Rinse. Repeat.

And so on and so forth. Whatever projects or special assignments I've seen have been half-heartedly jammed in to fulfill a "quota" of annual projects. Hands-on projects and technology assignments are crammed into the curriculum. New topics are introduced with chalk and note sheets. There is no discovery. No curiosity. No "let's see what we can figure out". And certainly no application to the real world. It's tragic, because these kids are the ones who struggle the MOST with abstract concepts and would benefit the MOST from making connections to real world applications.

If I had pedagogical control of my classrooms right now, I would work to use applications for one of the basic topics we’re on now, like percent change. My students are having a hard time understanding the concept of percent change – and seem to be struggling with the concept of “percent” itself, for that matter. All they have been told was “move the decimal two places… in some direction”. They don’t understand why. In fact, they didn’t seem to grasp where the word “per cent” even means.

If I were to introduce this to my students, I would either have some real-world discounts or coupons on some products with which they would have some familiarity. I could use magazine coupons or make my own. I would set up stations in the room, and have the students “go shopping” as a group, and asses which would be the best deal for each product. I’d hear their thoughts on how best to evaluate and figure it out. Then, I’d show them how to calculate percents and percent change. After the lesson, I would have them look through the newspaper, bring in coupons, and do the research as to the best place to buy certain items. I could assign them each an item to buy, and they can find the cheapest place to buy it, after discounts (and maybe even free shipping) can be applied. The person or group to find the cheapest place to buy something in the class can get some kind of prize.

(My apologies for the late hour of this blog. I spent over an hour cleaning someone else’s dog's poo today, which is the perfect ending for a week in which nothing seemed to go right.)

Saturday, February 7, 2009

Why should students learn mathematics?

I believe students should learn math for a multitude of reasons.

For the hell of it: Math is cool. Well, at least it CAN be cool if presented that way. There are a lot of really neat things you can do with numbers and a lot of interesting things you can learn about the world around us. In fact, some of the most fascinating facts are not impressive UNTIL you can attach numbers to them. Math has all sort of interesting nuances and patterns and if you can get your students excited about that, you've done them a great service.

For Thought: mathematical practice helps students become better thinkers and problem solvers. They can approach problems systematically and logically. They can think analytically. They can approach situations from different perspectives, and find many ways to solve the same problem. People who are good at math can become good at solving problems, mathematical or otherwise.

For Money: Almost every job requires some basic knowledge of math. Some jobs are more math-intensive than others, but almost every profession requires the knowledge of some math. Being proficient in math and working with numbers (even in a technological way) is a highly valuable and marketable skill. Students need to learn math to be prepared for a professional world, especially in this globally competitive economy.

For Life: You never know when you’ll need math. Math has hundreds of application to the lay person. Balancing check books, doing taxes, splitting a dinner check, investing, shopping, home repairs, home decoration, applying for loans, sports, driving, politics... and even helping your children with homework. Plus, a person may one day realize they should have been a math teacher, and have to go back to school to retake all the math they learned in high school.

Monday, January 26, 2009

What do I want others to know about me?

My name is Lisa. I work in a high school as a special education instructional assistant. Working there has given me really great insight into the practice of teaching and classroom management. Although I obviously can't say I know what it's like to take full responsibility for a class of students, I feel like I'm slowing filling my "bag of tricks" and getting to try out what works and what doesn't. I'm also getting to know my students and how they think, both individually and as a collective "organism". One thing I am curious about is how, aside from projects, to tailor a lesson "individually" to each student. Especially working in special education rooms, I see how the students' abilities are so different from the other, I'm very interested to learn how to "tailor" a lesson so that every student is engaged.

Most of my day is watching students go over handouts and text book problems, grind out worksheet after worksheet, spit out the material on a test, and forget it a week later. I really want to be that teacher who makes math fun and... ... exciting. I loved the toilet paper activity because it was exploratory. I'd love to keep a list of those types of lessons.

I attended an international elementary school in another country growing up. One of my main goals as a teacher is to instill a respect, curiosity, and appreciation for other cultures; I hope my students view and approach the world (and its problems) from a global perspective. Problem is, I don't have any idea how to do that in a math class. I'm sure there are plenty of ways, but I haven't seen many yet. I'm excited to learn!